Skip to main content

APEX Lemon Law

Lemon Law FAQ

Lemon Law Questions & Answers

Plain-language answers to the questions California drivers ask most about Lemon Law, grouped by topic. Each answer is general information; your situation depends on your vehicle, warranty, and repair history.

Free case evaluation

Find out if your vehicle may qualify

About a minute, no obligation. All fields are required.

Demo form: nothing is sent or stored yet. Please don't include Social Security or account numbers.

Browse by topic

Find your question

59 questions in 12 topics. Choose a topic, or start a free case evaluation if you would rather talk it through. These answers are general legal information, not legal advice.

FAQ: Eligibility

Eligibility

More detail is in the eligibility guide.

What makes a car a lemon in California?

Generally, a new or warrantied vehicle with a defect covered by the manufacturer's express warranty that substantially impairs its use, value, or safety, which the manufacturer or its authorized repair facilities haven't fixed after a reasonable number of attempts.

Which vehicles are covered?

New vehicles bought or used primarily for personal, family, or household purposes; business vehicles under 10,000 pounds gross vehicle weight when the business has no more than five vehicles registered in California; dealer-owned vehicles and demonstrators sold with a new car warranty; and the chassis and drivetrain of motor homes.

Are motorcycles covered?

No. The Act's definition of a new motor vehicle excludes motorcycles and off-highway vehicles that aren't registered under the Vehicle Code.

Does it matter where I bought the vehicle?

Yes. The Act generally covers vehicles sold or leased in California. Certain members of the armed forces have specific protections for vehicles bought out of state under Civil Code section 1795.8.

What if the problem came from an accident or a modification?

The Act does not apply to a defect caused by unauthorized or unreasonable use after the sale. An unrelated accident or aftermarket part does not automatically end a claim, but the manufacturer may argue it caused the problem, so keep repair and maintenance records.

Does a minor annoyance count as a defect?

Usually not by itself. The defect must substantially impair the vehicle's use, value, or safety. A problem that seems small, such as a rattle or a warning light, can still qualify if it affects safety or would lower what a reasonable buyer would pay.

FAQ: Repair attempts

Repair attempts

More detail is in the eligibility guide.

How many repair attempts are required?

There is no fixed number. Within 18 months or 18,000 miles, the law presumes a reasonable number of attempts after two or more repairs for a defect likely to cause death or serious injury, four or more for the same defect, or more than 30 cumulative days out of service. Claims can also succeed outside these benchmarks.

Do "could not duplicate" visits count?

They can. If you presented the vehicle for the defect, the visit is part of the history even if no repair was made. Make sure the repair order records your complaint.

Do the days out of service have to be in a row?

No. The 30-day benchmark counts cumulative calendar days out of service for warranty repairs.

Do I have to notify the manufacturer directly?

For the repair-count parts of the presumption, you must have directly notified the manufacturer at least once, but only if the manufacturer clearly disclosed that requirement, usually in the warranty or owner's manual. A written notice is good practice either way.

My problems started after 18 months. Am I out of luck?

No. The 18-month / 18,000-mile period only controls when the presumption is available. A defect that appears later, while the warranty still applies, can still support a claim on the full repair history.

FAQ: Warranty coverage

Warranty coverage

More detail is in the California Lemon Law guide.

What if my warranty has expired?

You may still have a claim if the defect was first reported to an authorized repair facility while the warranty applied. Filing deadlines still apply.

How long must the manufacturer take to repair the vehicle?

Unless you agree in writing to more time, warranty repairs must conform the vehicle to the warranty within 30 days. Delays beyond the manufacturer's control extend that period (Civil Code section 1793.2(b)).

What is warranty tolling?

The warranty period is automatically extended by the time the vehicle is in the shop for warranty repair, counted from the day you deliver it until it is returned or you are told it is ready (Civil Code section 1795.6).

What if the dealer says it is fixed, but it is not?

Tell the manufacturer or seller within 60 days after the repair. If you do, the warranty is not treated as expired for that problem, even if the warranty period has otherwise run out.

What should a repair order show?

The date you dropped the vehicle off, the mileage, your complaint, the work performed, and the date it was returned or you were told it was ready. The repair facility must give you a work order or receipt with the return date.

Is an extended service contract a warranty?

Usually not the manufacturer's express warranty. A service contract may or may not support a Lemon Law claim, so include it with your documents for review.

FAQ: Costs and transport

Costs and transport

More detail is in the buyback and replacement guide.

What if my car cannot be driven to the dealer?

If the vehicle cannot reasonably be delivered because of the defect, notify the manufacturer in writing. It must then repair the vehicle where it is, pick it up, or arrange transport at its own expense (Civil Code section 1793.2(c)).

Can I recover towing and rental car costs?

Reasonable repair, towing, and rental car costs you actually incurred are incidental damages included in a repurchase or replacement. Keep every receipt.

Are dealer add-ons refunded in a buyback?

Restitution covers manufacturer-installed options, transportation charges, and official fees, but excludes nonmanufacturer items installed by a dealer or the buyer. How specific add-ons are handled is a question for review.

FAQ: Buyback and replacement

Buyback and replacement

More detail is in the buyback and replacement guide.

What remedies are available?

Possible outcomes include a repurchase (restitution), a replacement vehicle, or a negotiated settlement. Civil penalties of up to two times actual damages may be available for willful violations, and a buyer who prevails may recover attorney fees and costs.

Can I choose a refund instead of a replacement?

Yes. The buyer may choose restitution instead of a replacement and cannot be required to accept a replacement vehicle.

Will I receive a full refund?

Not automatically. The manufacturer may deduct a usage offset: the price paid or payable multiplied by the miles driven before the first repair visit for the defect, divided by 120,000.

What does a replacement vehicle include?

A new vehicle substantially identical to the one replaced, with all the express and implied warranties of a new vehicle. The manufacturer pays the sales or use tax, license, registration, and other official fees for it.

What is "cash and keep"?

A negotiated settlement in which you keep the vehicle and receive a payment. It is not a statutory remedy and usually requires releasing your claims.

What happens to my car loan in a buyback?

The lender is generally paid what is owed from the repurchase, and the remaining refund goes to you. Rolled-over negative equity from a prior vehicle can complicate the numbers and needs review.

FAQ: Dispute programs

Dispute programs

More detail is in the process guide.

What is a manufacturer dispute resolution program?

Some manufacturers run a third-party arbitration program for warranty disputes. When the program is certified by the state, it can affect how the presumption and civil penalties work.

Do I have to use the program before I sue?

No. If a qualified program exists and you were properly told about it, you must use it before relying on the 18-month / 18,000-mile presumption, but not before filing a lawsuit.

How do I know if a program is state-certified?

The Department of Consumer Affairs Arbitration Certification Program certifies and monitors these programs and lists them on its website.

What is the New Motor Vehicle Board?

A State of California board whose Consumer Mediation Services Program is an informal, no-cost dispute resolution program for consumers. Using it is optional and does not replace your rights under the Song-Beverly Act.

Does a dispute program affect civil penalties?

It can. The separate penalty route for failing to repurchase or replace does not apply if the manufacturer maintains a qualified dispute program, although a penalty for willful violations may still be available.

FAQ: Used and leased vehicles

Used and leased vehicles

More detail is in the used car guide.

Can a used vehicle qualify?

Only in limited situations. After Rodriguez v. FCA US, LLC (2024), a used vehicle sold with the balance of the original warranty generally isn't a "new motor vehicle." A warranty from the seller can create its own obligations under Civil Code section 1795.5.

Is a certified pre-owned vehicle covered?

It depends on who issued the certified pre-owned warranty and its terms. Have the CPO documents reviewed.

How long is the implied warranty on a used car?

When a used vehicle is sold with an express warranty, the implied warranty lasts as long as the express warranty, but not less than 30 days or more than three months.

Are leased vehicles covered?

Yes. A lessee has the same rights against the manufacturer as a buyer under Civil Code section 1795.4. Read more in the leased vehicle guide.

Can I turn in my leased car while a claim is pending?

Get advice first. Turning the car in, buying it out, or transferring the lease can change or end a claim, and some procedures require the vehicle to stay available for inspection. Read more in the leased vehicle guide.

Are electric vehicles covered?

Yes, on the same terms as gasoline vehicles. Battery, charging, and software defects can qualify when they substantially impair the vehicle and aren't fixed after a reasonable number of attempts. Read more in the electric vehicle guide.

FAQ: Buying a vehicle

Buying a vehicle

More detail is in the used car guide.

Attorney review: confirm CARS Act details

What is the CARS Act three-day right to cancel?

Starting October 1, 2026, a dealer may not sell or lease a used vehicle priced at $50,000 or less at retail without giving the buyer a three-day right to cancel. The right ends if the vehicle is driven more than 400 miles after signing.

Is there a fee to cancel under the CARS Act?

A restocking fee is allowed: 1.5 percent of the sale price, with a $200 minimum and $600 maximum, plus $1 per mile over 250 miles, capped at $150.

Is the CARS Act cancellation part of Lemon Law?

No. It is a separate consumer protection that applies whether or not the vehicle has a defect. It replaced the older two-day contract cancellation option.

What does "Lemon Law Buyback" on a title mean?

When a manufacturer reacquires a vehicle under the Lemon Law and resells it in California, the title must be branded "Lemon Law Buyback" and a decal attached to the vehicle.

Will I be told if a car I am buying was a buyback?

You should be. The manufacturer must give the next buyer a written disclosure notice to sign, and a dealer who knows a vehicle was a buyback must give the same notice.

FAQ: Fees and penalties

Fees and penalties

More detail is in the buyback and replacement guide.

Who pays the attorney fees?

The Song-Beverly Act allows a buyer who prevails to recover reasonable attorney fees and costs from the manufacturer. Your fee arrangement with any law firm should be explained in a written agreement before representation begins.

How are attorney fees measured if I win?

The court awards costs and expenses, including attorney fees based on the actual time spent, in an amount it finds reasonable for the case.

When can a civil penalty be awarded?

If the manufacturer willfully failed to comply with the Act, a civil penalty of up to two times actual damages may be awarded. It is not available for claims based only on the implied warranty.

What happens to a fee dispute before a lawsuit?

For manufacturers that elected the AB 1755 procedures, the Department of Consumer Affairs summarizes the rules as sending pre-litigation disputes over attorney fees and costs to neutral, binding arbitration.

FAQ: The process

The process

More detail is in the process guide.

How long do I have to bring a claim?

For manufacturers that elected the AB 1755 procedures, an action generally must be filed within one year after the express warranty expires and no later than six years after original delivery, with tolling. Other claims follow different limitation periods, so speak with an attorney promptly.

Does AB 1755 apply to my manufacturer?

Only if the manufacturer elected to be covered by the new procedures. The Department of Consumer Affairs keeps the list of electing manufacturers.

What is the AB 1755 pre-suit notice?

For electing manufacturers, before seeking civil penalties, the consumer must send the manufacturer a written notice with the contents the statute specifies, demanding repurchase or replacement. The Department of Consumer Affairs describes it as a demand made at least 30 days before suing, sent to the email or mailing address the manufacturer publishes for Lemon Law notices.

What happens after the pre-suit notice?

The manufacturer may ask to inspect the vehicle within 30 days and may offer to repurchase or replace it within 30 days of the notice. If you accept, it must complete the repurchase or replacement within 60 days.

Will my case go to court?

Not necessarily. Many claims resolve through negotiation, a dispute program, or mediation. If a lawsuit is filed, most cases still settle before trial.

How long does a case take?

It varies with the manufacturer, the evidence, and the procedures that apply. No one can promise a specific timeline or outcome.

Should I keep driving the car?

Only if it is safe. If the defect makes the vehicle unsafe, stop driving it and notify the dealer and the manufacturer in writing. Keep it insured and registered, and don't sell or trade it in without advice.

FAQ: Documentation

Documentation

More detail is in the vehicle defects guide.

What documents should I keep?

The purchase or lease contract, warranty booklet, every repair order, messages with the dealer and manufacturer, a symptom log, and receipts for towing, rentals, or repairs you paid for.

I lost some repair orders. What should I do?

Ask the dealer in writing for copies. Dealers can usually print them from their service records.

Should I record the problem?

Yes. A short video or a photo of a warning message, with the date and mileage, helps show an intermittent defect is real.

FAQ: Consultation

Consultation

More detail is in the contact page.

Confirm free evaluation before publication

Is the case evaluation free?

Yes, we offer a free case evaluation.

Does contacting a law firm create an attorney-client relationship?

No. Submitting an inquiry does not create an attorney-client relationship. Representation begins only after a written agreement is signed with the firm.

Do I need to visit an office?

Not necessarily. Much of a Lemon Law case can be handled by phone, email, and secure document upload.

Free case evaluation

Still taking your car back to the dealer?

Tell us what's been happening. We'll review the details and explain whether California Lemon Law may apply. You don't need to visit an office to get started.

  • Have your repair orders nearbyApproximate dates and mileage are fine to start.
  • Describe the problem in your own wordsWhat happens, how often, and what the dealer said.

Serving drivers throughout California

Map for geographic reference only. Service availability is confirmed during your evaluation.

Free case evaluation

Request a free case evaluation

All fields are required. We'll follow up to learn more.

Demo form: nothing is sent or stored yet. Please don't include Social Security or account numbers.